I have been severely depressed for the last two or three weeks. Two? Three? I've lost count of the days. I feel nauseated and unrelentingly fatigued. The effort it takes to pedal my bike to school is laughable. The effort it takes to shower and dress is laughable. I have been keeping to my apartment and sleeping for most of the day. Moreover, I am bored by discussions of my depression. I'd rather have remained silent and posted my entry on receptor theory. Feeling this intense desire for an outlet is depressing in and of itself.
I've been trying to will myself not to fall behind. It's the end of a semester in which I've found it difficult to efficiently manage my time and concentrate. I did not do well on two exams at the beginning of the semester. Over the last few weeks, though, I've made dramatically better grades. So I don't want to blow it now. I have two course papers to write and my share of a grant application to finish. Presently, I am trying to will myself to shower and then finish my post on receptor theory. This last kills two birds with one stone, as the post is really an attempt to understand material that will be on my Principles of Pharmacology final.
I am very, very, very tired of no one understanding my point of view. Here's my point of view: I am cumulatively angry and exhausted. I am putting a lot of energy into affording people the respect that they don't afford me. I want the catty comments about my having to study hard to earn A's or ask for help with Schild analysis to end. "Oh, I never studied after class." "Oh, I had to learn that on my own." In the smug, smug under-the-guise-of-friendliness tone. Look, you're a fucking biochemistry major. I'm a fucking English major. How many people could successfully take on a PhD program in pharmacology and neurobiology after having majored in English literature? I'm tired of not getting credit for that. I'm sick of people insulting me when I haven't insulted them; that includes some of my fellow grad students as well as the asshole outside of our department who trained me how to do something recently.
I'm tired of white feminists who don't give a damn about bigotry against black people even as they're castigating "the black community", which doesn't fucking exist, for not giving a damn about bigotry against gays and lesbians. No, wait. It's more specific than that. I'm tired of white feminists who refuse to condemn bigotry against black people with the same compassion and attentiveness with which they condemn bigotry, namely sexism, against white women. In order to get taken seriously, I must confine myself to discussions of explicit statements of bigotry against black people, but you don't have to do the same when it comes to bigotry against white women? You get to talk about "context", "tone" and "implication", but I don't? You're capable of developing a nuanced understanding of manifestations of sexism against white women, but you still think that my anger and hurt and frustration are only legitimate if they're in response to cartoonishly overt manifestations of racism against blacks? Really, this kind of isolation fills me with despair. I can't stand everyone's tacit approval of this sort of thing anymore. I don't want to feel like the only person in the blogosphere who understands that it cuts both ways: There are wrongheaded black activists who don't care about bigotry against other groups of people, but there are also wrongheaded white feminists who don't care about bigotry against other groups of people, because human beings are glorified chimpanzees, and dumbassery is an equal opportunity employer.
I'm tired of people not understanding that racism against any group of people is comprised of a set of ideas, and that ideas are culturally, not biologically, transmitted. This means that it is totally possible to be racist against yourself. Jeezus fuck, no one comprehends this. I am so tired of reading blog after blog comment, by self-identified white authors in most cases, about how "there's no way that so-and-so could be racist against black people, because he's black himself". Hahahahahahahahahahaha. Trust me. I'm an American. I did not grow up in a cultural vacuum, and I know all about being racist against oneself.
I'm tired of no one understanding that I'm fundamentally tired of everyone who does something in this line. No one understands that I tend to fixate on examples of racism against black/brown people only because most of the stereotyping I'm personally subjected to has to do with my being half-black. My need to express my anger over racism against blacks isn't some sort of hypocritical sanction of bigotry against numerous other groups of people, including gays and lesbians and whites. Nor is it a "liberal" call for the government to violate people's right to free speech. It's me giving voice to my experience. It's the product of a great deal of repressed fury over the years. It's my painful disappointment in the predominantly white skeptics' and atheists' cliques who disingenuously use examples of blacks denigrating gays and lesbians to excuse their own unexamined prejudices against and caricatures of blacks. It's my exhaustion over constantly having to encounter the defensive, reflexive, burningly self-righteous resistance to sympathizing with a perspective such as mine. I'm surrounded by an abject lack of introspection. I'm sick, sick, sick and damn tired of feeling invisible. Who wants to feel invisible? Who wants to feel worthless?
I'm tired of the idea that you have to be indifferent to an issue in order to skeptically evaluate it. By the way, why does this rule never seem to apply to skeptics who crow fervently about their opposition to "political correctness"-- whatever the hell that is-- and who eagerly accept every sensationalist claim ever made by someone styling himself as an evolutionary psychologist? Why does this rule only seem to apply to "liberal" skeptics, skeptics who are angry about sexism against women and skeptics who are angry about racism against brown people? Anyway, this idea is poppycock. It is entirely possible to fairly and skeptically evaluate an argument while simultaneously harboring intense feelings about the issue in question. There is even a neurological, not a sociological, hypothesis that the brain's ability to generate emotions is inextricable from its ability to logically evaluate the world. Moreover, you are fucking insulting me by asking me to be indifferent towards questions such as "Are blacks really dumber than whites?" By ignoring my efforts to treat all questions as worthy of investigation and support intellectual and academic freedom in favor of condemning me for so much as one quiver of my mouth, you are being hypocritical, you are being irrational, you are being breathtakingly cruel, and you are insulting me to the very bone.
This post is titled "The Deep Well of Major Clinical Depression" for a reason: I don't feel like dealing with all the readers who will inevitably be tempted to tell me that my feelings aren't legitimate because I wrote a rant instead of a dispassionate essay with citations. Yeah, I get that this is an angsty post. I sound a little like my grunge-listening teenaged self in the '90's. I am sure that there do exist people out there who understand and sympathize with my perspective. My point is that I don't trust anyone, and I feel alone most of the time.
11 comments:
[sarcasm]
Juniper, I can't for the life of me imagine how someone could be so shallow and thin-skinned as to take attacks on her humanity personally.
[/sarcasm]
Shit. Sorry for the explicit tags, but I wasn't about to take chances and I can't think of anything half so expressive as sarcasm in this case.
Usual comments, as usual, apply.
Your feelings are legitimate. And I'm struggling physically in the same way as you describe. It's the end of a very, very, VERY long semester. Hang in there.
You never, ever sound like an angsty teenager. Even when you're exhausted and still managing more than most of the people around you, you are so damned analytical and insightful you sometimes make me wonder why I bother to write.
I'm passing this on because people need to read large chunks of it. I hope they have the grace to go away and think about it when they're done instead of going on the offense in their defense.
Picture a woman cheering and clapping wildly, because that's what I'm doing. These things needed to be said, and said harshly. I'm glad you did.
Best of luck to you. I hope you get out of the well soon.
Self-identified white male feminist here to thank you for writing this. What you're going through sucks and is wrong, but you and your words and your thoughts and your feelings are all real and matter and deserve to be treated with respect and taken seriously.
Not that some random person's affirmation is all that, but Juniper? I read nothing here I could disagree with. You're right. You're also intelligent and insightful and quite plainly working hard on your studies.
Now I'm going to go quietly reread your post a few times. Learning how to not be part of the problem is important to me.
You're right as usual (says a lurker). I feel bad, because you are talking about a particular bag of shit I see many of my black friends having to drag around. It's not fair. I am afraid that someday it will become too much and they will get too tired to continue, and I don't know how to help take that weight off.
It's been a long semester. "Just Dance" was my theme song last year as I was finishing my dissertation. Keep it up.
I'm tired of the idea that you have to be indifferent to an issue in order to skeptically evaluate it.
It helps, but it's not essential. To my way of thinking, the sign of a truly enlightened mind is to be able to recognize nonsense that you're inclined to believe.
Why does this rule only seem to apply to "liberal" skeptics, skeptics who are angry about sexism against women and skeptics who are angry about racism against brown people?
"Seem to apply" is the important phrase there. We tend to recognize good points or arguments when we we're inclined to agree with them.
Good luck with your studies. I think it was a lot easier for me, since I went right from studying math and science in high school to studying it in college. Nowadays, they don't even seem to teach those subject areas as well in high school as they used to, and you've had a long layoff besides.
It helps, but it's not essential.
I made the precise statement that one does not have to be indifferent to an issue in order to skeptically evaluate it. Moreover, the point of my statement in context, which you seem to have missed, is that many skeptics who are not at all indifferent to controversial issues nevertheless selectively demand indifference to those issues from others in exchange for giving them a hearing. This is irrational and unfair. Not to mention impractical: There are precious few human beings who are truly indifferent to incendiary topics!
There is nothing in my statement that precludes your point. I'm left wondering why you felt the need to make it.
To my way of thinking, the sign of a truly enlightened mind is to be able to recognize nonsense that you're inclined to believe
It is my goal to fairly and logically evaluate claims about the world. It is not my goal to be deemed the possessor of a "truly enlightened mind" by a random blogger who may or may not be discomfited by my deep-seated anger and my struggles with it.
"Seem to apply" is the important phrase there. We tend to recognize good points or arguments when we we're inclined to agree with them.
If you disagree with me about prevailing attitudes in skeptics' and atheists' groups, why didn't you explicitly say so? It would have been less condescending.
i was very, *very* alone in my first year of graduate school. i was Different. Rough Around The Edges. and as such was Intimidating OMG. there were other cultural differences at play, though nothing like the specific hurt you are being subjected to. and i am sorry that you have to put up with that fucking bullshit.
those fuckers tried to cut me down at every step. and i hated them. i hated it all. and yet, i learned to take pleasure in their wordless frustration as i refused to let them win.
in hindsight, of course, it is much clearer than it is from the middle of the muck.
keep going. once you get through your classes and into your lab work, these fuckwits will hardly matter anymore.
Coming to this late, but I really feel the need to say something - to offer some empathy and hugs and hopes that things are going a little better. It's so hard sometimes, to follow your own drummer.
And I have particular empathy for the studying - I switched to a very different area of science, one I'd dropped at school at the age of 13 and never touched since, for my final year at university, and so that year and the first year of my PhD I felt like I was constantly reaching for the dictionary or the basic textbooks just so I could understand the title of the lecture or paper, never mind the content. And the rest of the student cohort were basically patronising or just unkind. But it was worth it, I think!
As difficult as it is for you now, and as difficult as life has likely to some degree always been, please remember that the people who shape this world for the better are most often those who've had a terrible fucking go of things for practically their entire stay on Earth. The reason you face such an ongoing test, relentless in its intensity, is because you're allowing yourself to be molded into something more complex than the petty, jealous and base natures surrounding you. They don't understand how difficult it is to pursue truth past the point of comfort-all they can grasp are the products of this goal with easily recognizable labels: a beautiful, intelligent woman who came to qualify equally among them without having completed one of the programs to which they've each pinned the whole of their identities-the only measuring stick they have for feeling significant in a confusing, unpredictable world. You're likely viewed as a threat to perceived normalcy; an unanticipated outlier in their carefully constructed but fundamentally flawed model of self-worth. I know you're tired -- but you are going to find solid ground to stand on soon, even if it doesn't last for what feels long enough before things dip right back down. You've been set on the advanced course of life, and time is limited. I don't think those too-brief moments when the clouds of misery dissipate are accidental twists of fate - they seem to provide us with a very necessary chance to grab on for dear life to any hope we can find, enabling us to keep going for a little while longer. It's really impossible not to ever lose heart in the midst of battle, and some days, as you are expertly aware, you will feel the full weight of a gradually expanded understanding bear down on your shoulders. I hope you will always get back up, because you aren't finished yet-there's some piece of truth out there with your name on it.
So long as you retain small keepsakes of your real self (as you are periodically granted access to it) as a reference for later-you, and remember to be kind at best and tolerant at worst regardless of the shite personalities you encounter-you will be continually pushed along by that still-mysterious force toward those things you are meant for. And the soul-satisfaction that results from pursuing what you know to be purposed for you from the very start is a very real thing. Just ask Eva Curie-she wrote a whole book about her mother's miserable-blissful pursuit of purpose. I could send you my copy if you'd like.
You are exceptional. Life is not going to be easy for you- that's part of the deal. Your reward is understanding.
You can do this.
Post a Comment